US abstains as UN condemns Israeli settlements

 Public Opinions International
NEWYORK, 23rd December 2016

The UN Security Council has passed a resolution demanding that Israel stop building settlements in the occupied Palestinian Territories, after the US abstained in spite of ferocious criticism from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government.

The resolution was passed with 14 votes from the 15-member security council, hours after a senior Israeli official accused US President Barack Obama of working “behind Israel’s back” to cook up the resolution, in a broadside against the outgoing government of Israel’s closest ally. 

The verbal assault came a day after Egypt proposed and then withdrew a resolutioncalling on Israel to end the settlement activity. Mr Netanyahu’s government saw the initiative as a parting shot from Mr Obama’s administration after years of strained relations.

The US abstention sparked recriminations on Capitol Hill, where Paul Ryan, the Republican speaker of the House of Representatives, and John McCain, the Republican chairman of the Senate armed services committee, said it was “a blow to peace” and “shameful”.

President-elect Donald Trump reacted with a tweet: “As to the U.N., things will be different after Jan. 20th.”

Mr Trump’s administration, which takes office on January 20, is expected to be much more lenient towards Israel, and the president-elect has promised to move the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, which the Palestinians also consider their capital.

Ahead of the vote, Washington had not said whether it would exercise its veto — as it has done repeatedly over decades to protect Israel from critical UN resolutions — or abstain to allow the resolution to pass. 

“President Obama and secretary [of state John] Kerry are behind this shameful move against Israel at the UN,” a senior Israeli official said ahead of the vote. “The US administration secretly cooked up with the Palestinians an extreme anti-Israeli resolution behind Israel’s back which would be a tailwind for terror and boycotts and effectively make the western wall occupied Palestinian territory.” 

The Jewish holy site at the Western Wall in Jerusalem’s Old City is considered Israeli-occupied Palestinian territory by the international community, but Israel considers all of Jerusalem its unified capital and annexed the city’s eastern half in 1980. 

“President Obama could declare his willingness to veto this resolution in an instant, but instead is pushing it,” the senior official said. “This is an abandonment of Israel which breaks decades of US policy of protecting Israel at the UN and undermines the prospects of working with the next administration of advancing peace.” 

The remarks were made to the Financial Times by the senior Israeli official speaking on condition of anonymity.

US officials are concerned about a draft law before the Israeli Knesset that would legalise settler outposts in the occupied West Bank. They regard it as one of several steps by the Netanyahu government, which includes several pro-settler ministers, that will make the creation of a viable Palestinian state more difficult. 

On Thursday, Mr Trump intervened on Israel’s behalf, urging the US to veto the Egyptian resolution and accusing the UN of “showing systematic bias” against the Jewish state. After Mr Trump’s intervention, the Egyptian government withdrew its resolution. 

Later on Thursday, Mustafa Barghouti, a Palestinian politician and MP, told journalists at an official dinner that statements by Mr Trump and David Friedman, his nominee as ambassador to Israel, represented “a green light to initiation of annexing territories, especially Area C”.

Area C is the Israeli-administered part of the West Bank that Mr Netanyahu’s far-right allies in government are urging him to annex.

“Today’s vote is a blow to peace that sets a dangerous precedent for further diplomatic efforts to isolate and demonise Israel,” said Mr Ryan. “Our unified Republican government will work to reverse the damage done by this administration, and rebuild our alliance with Israel.”

Mr McCain joined Mr Ryan in calling the vote “another shameful chapter in the bizarre anti-Israel history of the United Nations”.

“The abstention of the United States has made us complicit in this outrageous attack, and marks a troubling departure from our nation’s long, bipartisan history of defending our ally Israel in the United Nations,” Mr McCain said. “This resolution will serve as yet another roadblock to peace between Israelis and Palestinians, and embolden the enemies of Israel.”

Lindsey Graham, a Republican South Carolina senator, said the vote would spark a US congressional backlash towards the UN, which he said was increasingly seen as being anti-Semitic.

“The United Nations will regret this vote and I hope the Obama Administration will realise the massive mistake they made on their way out of the door,” said Mr Graham. “With today’s abstention, the Obama Administration has empowered evil and been a very poor friend to democracy.”

Aipac, the powerful pro-Israel lobby group, said it was “deeply disturbed” by the failure of the Obama administration to veto the resolution, and thanked Mr Trump for his opposition to the measure.

“Unfortunately, the UNSC today irresponsibly adopted a ruinous resolution that can only make the goal of peace even more elusive,” Aipac said in a statement.

Israelis and Palestinians alike have criticised Mr Obama, who won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2009, for doing little to advance the cause of peace. During his administration, the US signed off on a record $38bn, 10-year military aid package for Israel, but clashed openly with Mr Netanyahu over the settlements, the Iran nuclear deal, and other issues.

The non-vetoing of the resolution will be seen as Mr Obama’s biggest legacy on the troubled Israeli-Palestinian peace process, and do something to salvage the US leader’s reputation among Palestinians who say he did little in eight years to bring their dream of a viable independent state any closer.

It will be condemned by Israel, which tried to rally the US, Egypt and other countries against the resolution, arguing that it was an anti-Israeli measure that would harden Palestinian negotiating positions and make the chances of peace more remote.

The resolution calls the settlements Israel has built on Palestinian lands since the 1967 Six Day War “a flagrant violation of international law”, demands Israel stop all settlement activities, and says the UN will not recognise any changes to Israel’s pre-1967 borders, including in Jerusalem.

While the resolution is not likely to have any real impact in the near term, analysts have speculated that it could open the door to future sanctions being placed on the settlements or Israeli institutions involved in supporting them. America’s decision not to wield its veto was greeted with jubilation in the West Bank.

“I think it’s a great victory for the Palestinian people and the Palestinian cause,” said Mustafa Barghouti, an MP and head of the Palestinian National Initiative, a political party. “It shows that the Palestinians aren’t isolated, it is Israel and those who are with it who are isolated.”

Mr Barghouti added that the resolution “opens the door for demanding sanctions and boycotts on Israeli activities”.

Non-governmental organisations that are critical of Israel’s 49-year-old occupation of Palestinian lands welcomed the vote. B’Tselem, one such group, said it “reaffirms international consensus that Israel’s settlements are illegal and harm Palestinian human rights”.

Israel’s foreign ministry said that it had no reaction to the resolution at this stage.


Disseminated Worldwide by;
Public Opinions International
Organisation for International Friends of Africa (OIFA)
Plot 30 Suite 5, Level 4 Green Land Tower

Opposite Bank of Uganda Kampala Road
P.o Box 35297 Kampala-Uganda
Tel: 256 701 992 426
Email:This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.